Tuesday, 16 June 2015

Which Ball is in Play?

Following last week’s blog, which I finished with a strong recommendation that players must put an identification mark on their balls if they want to avoid incurring unnecessary penalties, I received this interesting scenario;
"In a strokes competition, a player hits his tee shot in left rough. Goes to look for his ball, not finding after brief search, returns to the tee and hits a second ball into the same area. While looking for the second ball and finding a ball, a spectator advises that the ball he found is in the area where the first ball landed. Player cannot determine whether the ball he found is his first or second tee shot as both balls were marked the same. Player plays the ball found through the hole and asks for help in scoring to determine his score for the hole."
Initially, I thought that Situation 4 in Decision 27/11 provided the answer to this question (see below for the rulings on four interesting situations relating to a player who cannot distinguish between their original ball and their provisional ball in this Decision), but I have been corrected and I think that it is worth explaining where I went wrong. When a provisional ball is played onto the course there are two possible outcomes; the original ball may be found in bounds, in which case the provisional ball is then out of play, or the original ball is lost, in which case the provisional ball is the ball in play. The mistake that I was making in respect of the above question is that when the player returned to the teeing ground and put another ball in play, (Edit 17th June: which is not permitted to be a provisional ball) the first ball was immediately lost. So, when the player could not distinguish whether the ball that was found by the spectator was his original ball (lost and not in play under the Rules) or the second ball (the ball in play under the Rules), he was not permitted to assume that the found ball was his second ball. Therefore, his only way to proceed within the Rules was to return to the teeing ground and play another ball, his 5th stroke. Failure to do so meant that he was disqualified from the strokes competition, because he did not hole out with the correct ball.

Here is Decision 27/11 in full, which explains the principle when a provisional ball has been played;

A player entitled to play a provisional ball from the tee plays it into the same area as his original ball. The balls have identical markings and the player cannot distinguish between them. Following are various situations and the solutions, which are based on equity (Rule 1-4), when the above circumstances exist and one or both of the balls are found within a search of five minutes:

Situation 1: One ball is found in a water hazard and the other ball is not found.

Solution 1: The ball that was found must be presumed to be the provisional ball.

Situation 2: Both balls are found in a water hazard.

Solution 2: As the player's original ball is lost in the water hazard due to his inability to identify it (see analogous Decision 27/10), the player must proceed under Rule 26-1 with respect to the original ball (estimating the spot where the ball last crossed the margin of the hazard, if necessary - see Decision 26-1/17); his next stroke would be his third.

Situation 3: One ball is found in bounds and the other ball is lost or is found out of bounds.

Solution 3: The ball in bounds must be presumed to be the provisional ball.

Situation 4: Both balls are found in bounds, whether in a playable or an unplayable lie, and (1) one ball is in a water hazard and the other is not or (2) both balls lie through the green or in a bunker.

Solution 4: One could argue that both balls are lost. However, it would be inequitable to require the player to return to the tee, playing 5, when the player has found both balls but does not know which is the original and which the provisional. Accordingly, the player must select one of the balls, treat it as his provisional ball and abandon the other.
Remember that the principle in Situation 4 does not apply to the question at the start of this blog, because no provisional ball was involved.

Good golfing,


If you would like to have the full set (99 issues) of either of my two complete ‘Rhodes Rules School’ series in a single .pdf file, please click on these links;

Series 1: ‘Photo Series’

Series 2: ‘How Many Strokes?'

The current series, '9 Questions About ...' will be available at the start of next year.

The above content is strictly copyright to Barry Rhodes © 2015 and may not be copied without permission.


dick kusleika said...

I think the golfer lost his opportunity to hit a provisional once he went forward from the tee box a significant amount to search for his ball. Even if he had declared his second shot provisional, it would not have been.

In that case where he declares a provisional, but isn't allowed to, does the second ball become the ball in play?

Dick Jonkers said...

I don't agree with the explanation : ".......when the player returned to the teeing ground and put another ball in play, without announcing it as a provisional ball, the first ball was immediately lost".

According R 27-2a going back to the teeing ground ( unless it is < 50 yards Dec. 27-2a/1.5) means that that ball is not a provissional ball and becomes the ball in play.

Barry Rhodes said...


Of course, you are correct. What was I thinking? I have now corrected this facile mistake.

Thanks to you and many others who spotted this error for taking the time to advise me.



Anonymous said...

I carry a couple of yellow balls marked like my normal white balls and use one as the provisional if necessary, saves problems (unless I have to hit 2 provisionals, if so just mark the second differently, or record a blob if stapleford)

ps Just bought 999 - great !

Jane said...

Phew I thought I was going mad, and was about to leave the same message.

Barry Rhodes said...


Good tip! I have recently started doing this myself.

I am pleased to hear that you are finding my '999 Questions' eBook useful.


Barry Rhodes said...

Dick Kusleika,

Mea culpa. I am scarlet with embarrassment!